The inquiry commission, probing November 2017 Faizabad sit-in, absolved former director-general of the Inter-Service Intelligence (ISI) Lt. Gen. (retd) Faiz Hameed of all charges.
The three-member commission, set up on the orders of the Supreme Court, issued its 149-page report the other day.
According to sources, the commission cited various loopholes in the handling of the issue and prepared recommendations after evaluating the circumstances related to the Tehreek-e-Labbaik Pakistan’s sit-in at Faizabad.
The report highlights the role of Islamabad Police, Ministry of Interior, Punjab Government, ISI and IB, and contains details of matters related to former law minister Zahid Hamid.
The report stated that Faiz Hameed, as Major General DG (C) ISI, was authorised by the then army chief and the ISI director-general to sign the agreement with protesters. Moreover, then prime minister Shahid Khaqan Abbasi and interior minister Ahsan Iqbal also agreed on Gen (retd) Faiz Hameed as a mediator.
The commission stressed on ensuring implementation of all the points of the National Action Plan and recommended that weaknesses in the command and control system of the police should be addressed.
The inquiry commission pointed out that Faizabad like incidents occur because of flaws in the government policy. It stressed on “policy makers” to learn lessons from the Faizabad incident.
The report held the Punjab government responsible for “allowing the TLP to proceed to Islamabad instead of halting it in Lahore.”
The report also highlighted that a lack of communication in the police of twin cities resulted in deaths and hundreds of injuries.
The report mentioned that the federal government got the services of the ISI to gain access to the leadership of the protesters.
It stated that on November 25, 2017, an agreement was reached with the cooperation of the ISI and the protesters dispersed.
During the sit-in, military officers, Nawaz Sharif and ministers were threatened on social media, and the government failed to take action against the social media, the report added.
The commission said that during the Faizabad sit-in, Shehbaz Sharif was the chief minister of Punjab. None of the country’s leadership at that time blamed any institution or official for the incident. Interference by the military or an agency in a civilian matter seriously affects the institution’s reputation.
The commission suggested that army should not get involved in public affairs to avoid criticism. Handling of civilian affairs is the responsibility of IB and civil administration, it added.
The commission found the government of Punjab “negligent and weak” which led to bloodshed. Steps should be taken to end faith-based violence. The state should not compromise on the constitution, human rights, democracy and the rule of law.
The commission suggested that police officers should be deployed in difficult areas before being deployed in Islamabad.
“Public order is the responsibility of the government; other institutions should avoid interference. Zero tolerance policy is mandatory to deal with violent extremism,” the report concluded.
The inquiry commission was headed by former IG Syed Akhtar Ali Shah, and included former IG Tahir Alam and senior officer of Pakistan Administrative Service Khushal Khan.
