The Supreme Court of Pakistan adjourned hearing till next Tuesday (May 23) on the Election Commission of Pakistan’s plea for a review of the apex court’s April 4 order, which directed the holding of elections in Punjab on May 14.
A three-member bench headed by Chief Justice Umar Ata Bandial comprising Justice Ijaz Ul Ahsan and Justice Munib Akhtar heard the case.
Today’s hearing
At the outset of the hearing, CJP Bandial on ECP’s plea remarked that the electoral watchdog in its petition raised fair points in its review petition.
“We will issue notices to other party political parties including the Punjab and KP provincial government,” added top judge.
The points raised by ECP were not raised earlier. We want to hear ECP on the admissibility of the plea, the CJP remarked.
To which PTI’s lawyer Ali Zafar argued that the scope of a review petition was confined and prohibited the introduction of new points. He emphasized that the review petition should be limited in its focus.
Read also: Parliament should review CJP’s conduct, send reference against him: Asif
Responding to this contention, the Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP) expressed the court’s interest in hearing the Election Commission of Pakistan’s (ECP) arguments regarding the maintainability of the petition.
Furthermore, the CJP announced that notices would be issued to the provincial governments to present their respective positions on the matter, along with representatives from other political parties involved.
During the proceedings, the CJP emphasized the government’s order as being final, indicating the importance of the decision at hand.
CJP further remarked while ordering the authorities to satisfy the court about their conduct “There is a 90-day period [for conducting elections] according to the Constitution. If there was the order for holding polls on May 14 then it should have been implemented.”
There are “mature political parties” on both sides, the top judge observed while adjourning the hearing till Tuesday (May 23).
The plea
The Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) has filed a review petition in the Supreme Court, requesting the court to reconsider its directives issued on April 4th. The directives pertained to the setting of election dates in the country. In its 14-page petition, the ECP argued that the judiciary does not have the authority to determine the dates of elections, and that such powers exist elsewhere under the Constitution.
The electoral watchdog stated in its petition that the Supreme Court should review its decision and correct the error made in assuming the role of a public body in giving a date for elections. The Commission cited various legalities and reasons behind its statement, pointing out that the apex court disregarded its constitutional jurisdiction.
The ECP emphasized that the Supreme Court’s intervention was necessitated to correct an error that had effectively changed the settled constitutional jurisprudence of the country. The electoral body accused the apex court of overstepping its boundaries and assuming powers that do not lie in a court of law.












